Bridge Builders:
David Valentine

The Englishman who spent 30 years bringing Scotland and China closer together

Caption
"I never thought I'd visit China"
David Valentine

Britain in the 1950s was not always a place that encouraged global thinking. Rationing introduced during World War II lasted until 1954 for meat, and as late as 1958 for petrol. Meanwhile, an empire that had girdled the planet and lasted for centuries was shrinking into a Commonwealth as far-flung dominions sought independence. 

But David Valentine was a bright and inquisitive child. Born in 1952 in Ramsbottom, a quaintly-named village in the cotton-spinning county of Lancashire in northwest England, the young Valentine saw a picture that fired his empathy and imagination – and although he wasn't to know it, it was to start a long association with the other side of the planet. 

"When I was five, I saw in a textbook a picture of a family in China. They were obviously a poor family in a rice field, and it made me very curious," he tells CGTN, his gentle Lancastrian burr only slightly diminished by decades away from his birth county.

"I tried to compare – 'What would their life be like compared with that of my family?' At the time, I was one of five children – two more came later. So in my early life, I used to think about that family and wonder how their life became."

It's not that the five-year-old Valentine decided there and then to up sticks and track them down – "I never thought I'd visit China; I never thought I'd have the opportunity" – but early in his adult life, he left Lancashire never to return. 

Caption

David (right) with his siblings aged four. /Valentine

David (right) with his siblings aged four. /Valentine

David (second left) on his street with his siblings. /Valentine

David (second left) on his street with his siblings. /Valentine

To Scotland

Caption

Sunrise on the Isle of Skye. /VCG

Sunrise on the Isle of Skye. /VCG

Caption

David married a local Scottish lassie. /Valentine

David married a local Scottish lassie. /Valentine

David had two sons with his wife in Angus. /Valentine

David had two sons with his wife in Angus. /Valentine

"When I was 19, I came to Scotland to study," recalls Valentine, who studied town and regional planning at Dundee University. "I was here for four years, but in my second year I met the love of my life Margaret, who was a Fifer, and I decided to put down roots here."

Fife is the historic county that stretches between Scotland's two great eastern estuaries, or 'firths' in the Scots language (it shares etymology with fjord, from the land of the invading Vikings across the North Sea). To the south is the Firth of Forth, on whose southern shore sits the Scottish capital Edinburgh; to the north is the Highlands-draining Firth of Tay, on whose northern shore is Scotland's fourth-largest city Dundee – and, slightly farther along the coast, the long-adopted home of David Valentine. 

In 1975, Valentine started what would become a 37-year career in local government. And two decades in, when he was interviewed to be Chief Officer of the newly re-established local government of Angus – a 2,000-square-kilometer chunk of eastern Scotland still named after an eighth-century king of that name – he knew that this ancient shire needed to look to the future… and to face eastwards.

"In June 1995, I was interviewed by all 29 councilors. I presented a 10-point action plan, and one of those 10 points was that we should and must engage with China," he recalls. 

"I strongly advised that even a small council could do some great things by engaging with local government in China, because China has a great respect for government-to-government relationships. I realized then that China would become a great super-economy."

A Chinese Twin

Caption

Yantai city, Shandong province, China. /VCG

Yantai city, Shandong province, China. /VCG

The first step was the establishment of a consulate in Edinburgh, in 1998. Next was a potentially agonizing decision: who to pair up with?  

Although the earliest example of inter-municipal buddying-up dates back almost 12 centuries to the 836 agreement between France's Le Mans and Paderborn in what was not yet Germany, the international diplomatic act of finding a twin town, or sister city, began in earnest in Europe after World War II – when David Valentine was still in Lancashire wondering about the Chinese family in his textbook. It was popularized by Coventry, whose mayor reached out to Stalingrad, then Dresden and Belgrade – fellow sufferers of terrible wartime bombing – in a spirit of cross-boundary reconciliation and increased mutual understanding. 

Valentine and his Angus council colleagues knew they wanted a similar relationship with a Chinese city, but which one? In the end, it was Yantai. With a prefecture-level population of almost seven million, the largest fishing seaport in the province of Shandong may not seem a natural partner for the relatively quiet Angus, but Valentine could see certain similarities – and a winning desire for cooperation. 

"We were only a very small council in Scotland with 110,000 people – but nonetheless, the Yantai government was very keen to engage with us," he recalls. "It was a good choice because it's situated in the north-east of China, as we are in the north-east of Britain."

But there was more than just geography in common: there was a harmony among the areas' historically dominant industries… not to mention a recent newcomer.

"There's a very strong agricultural base," Valentine says of Yantai. "There is fishing – there are about 76 commercial species of fish. Oil exploration was commencing in the Bohai Sea just off the coast; we have the North Sea oil, which had been developed in the 1970s.

" And what's more, the people were very direct, very open – people that you could really do business with," he continues. "So we began to talk about company engagement. We introduced businesses. We went out there every two years with a trade mission and we also attended many other conferences."

Caption

Chinese New Year in Edinburgh. /Valentine

Chinese New Year in Edinburgh. /Valentine

Offshore platform industry, /Yantai. /VCG

Offshore platform industry Yantai. /VCG

Golf: A shared passion

Caption

Carnoustie golf course, Angus. /VCG

Carnoustie golf course, Angus. /VCG

Caption

David Valentine owns Simpsons, the oldest golf shop in Scotland. /VCG

David Valentine owns Simpsons, the oldest golf shop in Scotland. /VCG

Chinese delegates visit Carnoustie golf resort for tartan week 2011. /VCG

Chinese delegates visit Carnoustie golf resort for tartan week 2011. /VCG

Golf is a curious sport: Long-distance tidying-up, using only various pointed sticks to poke a ball into a hole – with a points system based not on speed but minimal contact. It is, nevertheless, one of Scotland's most enduring exports, since emerging from the country around a millennium ago. 

It is also strongly linked with the world of business, with deals done every day around the course or in the clubhouse later. So it's no surprise that Valentine, seeking to clinch the deal, should lead his twinning delegations to admire the world-famous course at Carnoustie. 

"In January 1999, a delegation led by Vice Mayor Wang Shujian from Yantai came here to sign the final twinning agreement between Angus and Yantai," he says. "And I remember taking them to the then brand new hotel in Carnoustie overlooking the championship courses."

Understandably proud of a course that has hosted the British Open on eight occasions, Valentine might not have expected what happened next. "The head of the sister-city office looked out on the golf course and said, 'We've got one like this in China.'"

He moved fast: "We twinned that golf course with Carnoustie in 2002" – and it opened doors. " The owner of the course also owned the fabulous course Shanghai Silport, which was the venue for the China Open." Indeed, no course has hosted the China Open, which began in 1995, more often than Shanghai Silport's seven. And that link-up again boosted Carnoustie, and therefore Angus. 

"Golf is big in China, and over the years, that link between Yantai and Shanghai Silport and Carnoustie helped us to bring hundreds of golfers here and to promote Carnoustie all over China, not just in Shandong."

Not all twinning-related activities happen as quickly, and Valentine had to learn the value of patience and persistence. 

"It was very important to keep the communication and to keep engaging, because a lot of these twinning relationships are a bit like a butterfly – you know, nothing happens for three years or whatever," he explains. "I was very keen to make sure that we maintain that level of engagement and communication, and I think that was one of the strongest aspects of our relationship over many years. 

"In fact, I could walk into the sister-city office now and I'll know everyone, I'm still engaged with them. It's still a very important engagement for the benefits of businesses here, not not just in Angus, but in Scotland."

Old golf clubs in the workshop at Simpsons gold shop Carnoustie. /Mearns

Old golf clubs in the workshop at Simpsons gold shop Carnoustie. /Mearns

Glamis and the Great Wall

Glamis Castle in Scotland. /VCG

Glamis Castle in Scotland. /VCG

The twinning wasn't just about business and the future. Each region can draw on its history, and this presented the opportunity for another match-up.

The people of Angus are understandably proud of Glamis Castle, a name that resonates down the centuries. Scottish king Malcolm II was murdered there in 1034, which may have helped William Shakespeare base Macbeth's title character there (the actual king of that name didn't live at Glamis, but let's allow the playwright some poetic license). 

The wife of a later Lord Glamis was burned at the stake for alleged witchcraft, and in the 20th century the castle was the childhood home of Elizabeth Angela Marguerite Bowes-Lyon – later to become the wife of King George VI and mother of Queen Elizabeth II (whose sister Princess Margaret was born at Glamis Castle). 

Glamis Castle was home to Queen Elizabeth II's mother (top right) and Princess Margret was born there. /Mearns

Glamis Castle was home to Queen Elizabeth II's mother (top right) and Princess Margret was born there. /Mearns

But China, too, has its history – millennia of it. Penglai Pavilion is one of China's Four Great Towers, with the Dan Cliffs being the departure point for the Eight Immortals, a Chinese legend so beloved it has drawn emperors to Penglai and remains popular even in today's secular times. 

It was therefore a natural choice to be twinned with Glamis Castle – but it wasn't the only one: 

"We twinned the Great Wall of China with Glamis Castle," smiles Valentine, who was again a prime mover behind the cross-country cooperation. 

"I remember going along to meet the Great Wall Society and telling them the story about the royal connection," he says. "But it was when I mentioned that it was the place that Shakespeare based his Scottish story, Macbeth. And of course, a lot of people know of Shakespeare and the people I spoke to had heard about Macbeth."

Jinshanling Great Wall. /VCG

Jinshanling Great Wall. /VCG

With the deal done, Valentine also pulled off a coup – not the Shakespearean sort, but the publicity variety.  

"I managed to get a Chinese flag put on the castle and the BBC World Service took a helicopter view of it when the twinning was announced in October 2006. And that created a huge sway of publicity."

Caption

A Chinese chest in the living room at Glamis Castle. /VCG

A Chinese chest in the living room at Glamis Castle. /VCG

David Valentine often takes Chinese visitors to see the castle. /Mearns

David Valentine often takes Chinese visitors to see the castle. /Mearns

Item 1 of 5

Penglai, Shandong, China/ VCG

Penglai, Shandong, China/ VCG

Overlooking the scenery of Baxiandu scenic spot. /VCG

Overlooking the scenery of Baxiandu scenic spot. /VCG

Sculptures of the eight immortals, Penglai, China. /VCG

Sculptures of the eight immortals, Penglai, China. /VCG

The view from inside Penglai. /VCG

The view from inside Penglai. /VCG

The gates at Penglai, Shandong. /VCG

The gates at Penglai, Shandong. /VCG

Chinese-Scottish Tartan

Caption

Chinese-Scottish Tartan. /Valentine

Chinese-Scottish Tartan. /Mearns

Caption

Chinese Scottish tartan sells well to Chinese visitors to Angus. /Valentine

Chinese Scottish tartan sells well to Chinese visitors to Angus. /Valentine

The Chinese-Scottish tartan is also sold in Yantai. /Valentine

The Chinese-Scottish tartan is also sold in Yantai. /Valentine

Asked to name a handful of things that represent Scottishness, most people would include tartan. Known in some countries as plaid, these crisscrossed patterns of alternating color seem somehow definitively Scottish and ancient; the 1782 lifting of a ban on them allowed the fashion to proliferate and gain a romantic back-story. 

However, there has been an ancient link discovered between tartan and China. A tartan material was discovered on the 'Mummies of Urumchi' found in Xinjang desert region of China in 1978. Dating back 3000 years, the tribesmen's were 6ft tall, had round eyes, fair hair and large noses suggesting a more caucasian appearance. They were clad in plaid which resembled an ancient tartan woven thousands of years ago.

However, historians agree the wearing of such patterns was not particular to Scotland, only gaining emotional importance in retrospect. While certain tartan patterns are now ascribed to given clans or surnames, there's no legal block on new designs. As such, tartan gave Valentine another tantalizing tie-up possibility, when the opportunity presented itself in August 2005. 

"I heard Guo Guifang, the then Consul General based in Edinburgh, speaking about these iconic aspects of Scotland," he says. "And I said to her afterwards, 'Madam, do you have a tartan?' Because a tartan is not just about families – countries can have a tartan designed for them. And she said, 'No, I don't think we do.'"

No prizes for guessing what happened next. Local company Strathmore Woollens produced four designs, and Valentine is happy to brandish the winner. 

"This is the Chinese Scottish tartan," he explains. "You can see the Chinese flag and the Scottish flag, you can see the blue and the white of the saltire and you can see the red and yellow from the Chinese flag. 

"And where the yellow crosses the red, that is symbolic of the five stars of the Chinese flag. One is brighter than the others, and then the green, that is symbolic of the long-lasting relationship between Kunming and the Royal Botanical Gardens in Edinburgh, which has gone on since 1906, so very long established and it represents the harmony between our people."

A tartan week with people of Yantai. /Valentine.

A tartan fashion show in Yantai. /Valentine.

A common love of whisky

Caption

Whisky matures in barrels at Angus Dundee Distillery, Scotland. /Mearns

Whisky matures in barrels at Angus Dundee Distillery, Scotland. /Mearns

Tartan isn't the only Scottish export to have become an acquired taste around the world: Another is whisky. (That's the usual spelling in Scotland and much of the rest of the world, and although in Ireland and the U.S. the spelling is more often whiskey with an 'e', the usual convention is to respect the country of each brand's origin.)

According to the Scotch Whisky Association, every second of the day an average of 44 bottles are exported to around 180 markets around the world – that's more than 1.3 billion bottles a year. No surprise, then, that it came to Valentine's attention as another bridge to China. 

"In 2004 I introduced the local distillery, owned by Angus Dundee Distillers, to China," he says. "And in fact, Angus Dundee Distillers have a team of 10 now in Shanghai and they have customers all over China."

But in the true spirit – no pun intended – of twinning and reciprocity, the whisky didn't just flow from Scotland to China. In 2018, a company in Inner Mongolia sought an expert to help them set up an authentic distillery on Chinese soil. 

"MengTai asked me if I could help them source a supply of equipment for the new distillery, and I introduced them to a company in Scotland who at that time I felt produced the best equipment for the industry," explains Valentine. "The Scottish company has supplied the equipment to actually produce the malt whisky, from the point at which the malt grain is delivered to right to where it is put into the barrel."

What might have been one-off start-up advice grew into something much more enmeshed. "I built a strategic partnership between Angus Dundee Distillers and MengTai, which has been a great source of assistance. And it's based on not just providing the advice, technical support that's required, but also buying bulk whisky from Angus Dundee Distillers – so it's a win-win situation."

Caption

With Ao Fengting, Chairman of Meng Tai Group. /Valentine

With Ao Fengting, Chairman of Meng Tai Group. /Valentine

The new entrepreneur

Caption

Valentine in Strathmore Woollens. /Mearns

Valentine at Glamis Castle. /Mearns

Caption

Yibin Sichuan Province 2010. /Valentine

Yibin Sichuan Province 2010. /Valentine

Social media for the Confucius Institute of Scotland's schools.

Social media for the Confucius Institute of Scotland's schools.

By the time Valentine was making introductions between Angus Dundee Distillers and MengTai in 2018, he had reached the age of 66 and had, supposedly, retired. But a man of his vigor was unlikely to slow down too much, figuratively or literally – he still drives like a man late for an important appointment, dashing CGTN around Angus to meet people he finds fascinating. 

"I retired in 2012 after 37 years in local government," he says. "I'd performed a number of key roles in terms of supporting businesses in Scotland, particularly those in Angus. I was chair of the Business Gateway Scotland Board, which provided business support across the whole of Scotland.

"But I also wanted to continue the work being this bridge between Scotland and China, because having that independence would allow me to do things for Scotland more than just for Angus. 

"My time with Angus Council taught me that it's absolutely essential to have government to government relationships. In fact, in 2006, I was very active as a member of the Scottish Government's team that produced the first China plan – Scotland is, to my knowledge, the only country that I'm aware of that has a China plan and it's renewed every five years. I think this means a lot to the Chinese. 

"So the government-to-government relationship – setting the scene, creating the platform, the foundation – is hugely important, and maintaining those relationships."

But he hasn't only carried on at administrative level. "I've continued to introduce businesses: I perform a role as the International Trade Ambassador for China on behalf of the Scottish Chambers of Commerce. And in that role I've helped the Scottish Chambers of Commerce to open doors in China and to accelerate the pace of our advancement in terms of engaging businesses here in Scotland with those in China. 

"I've also engaged as an advisory board member of the Confucius Institute for Scotland Schools, something I have a great passion for, which is to help educate our young people to know more about China and to speak the language."

It's a growing concern. "We now have, I think, 46 hubs around Scotland... And we have Chinese studies in most of our secondary schools, something that I absolutely believe is a good thing for the future of our society as well as our business enterprises."

The award-winner

Such work has not gone unnoticed, with Valentine becoming the grateful recipient of several awards. "I was made an honorary citizen of Yantai in March 2008, and in November of that year I was made Ambassador of the Year here in Angus and China."

He has also received royal recognition. "The Queen awarded me the MBE imprinted on my lapel in July 2013 in Holyrood Palace in Edinburgh, a very special moment," he beams. "She asked me about my links and the engagement between Scotland and China."

The plaudits were not just in the UK. "Last year, the Shandong provincial government conferred honorary citizenship on me. You know, that's the highest honor that any province can give to a foreigner, so that's very special."

Building bridges

Caption

China has experienced unprecedented economic growth in the last two decades. /CGTN

China has experienced unprecedented economic growth in the last two decades. /CGTN

Valentine is well placed to witness the changes in China over the past quarter-century, and he pinpoints a specific sector as the most notable. 

"There's no doubt the economy in China has changed vastly in those 25 years that I've been involved. I think the biggest change that's happened is the growth in the middle classes," he says. 

"The fact that China has taken so many hundreds of millions out of poverty means that there is a huge ability as well as appetite for what we've got. So there's a great opportunity for our companies here not just to import from China, but to supply food, drink and other products that we manufacture here."

This growth has caused a boom in several sectors, but one is distinctly recognizable to a man who moved to Scotland in 1971, very shortly after the game-changing discovery of oil fields under the North Sea. 

"Yantai has become a very important center for offshore oil, so a whole array of related industries has developed," he says. "Scottish companies have had opportunities as a result of that – not just the companies who are involved in the supply for those businesses, but also our educational establishments."

The era of fossil fuels will not last forever, but Valentine thinks China is ahead of the game. "China is making great strides with low-voltage electric cars – I think it's going to go right past what's happening in the West," he says. "And these new industries bring opportunities for our professionals and for some of our supply-based industries."

It's all served to strengthen the point that Valentine made in that 1995 presentation to the Angus councilors. But Valentine insists the process of understanding China must continue and grow. 

"China is fast becoming the super-economy that some of us said it would, 25 years ago," he says. "So it's absolutely vital that our youngsters know more about China, can speak the language, so that as we develop our own businesses and culture, that we can engage more effectively."

That's a two-way street, he says, with his friends in the far East very knowledgeable about Scotland's extraordinary history of overachievement. 

"I think Scottish culture has so much going for it and the Chinese are very much aware of the Enlightenment period and of Scotland's contribution to the world of science and engineering and so on, all the great inventions. I mean, for a small country, I think we're punching way above our weight," he smiles.

In the end, it's not a competition but an opportunity for cooperation – and indeed friendship. "I've got friends all over China – in Beijing, in Guangzhou, in Sichuan Province," he says. "I've visited so many different places and made so many friends. I thoroughly enjoy every moment of my engagement with China."

The young Valentine would be very impressed with how the story turned out. "If I go back to when I was a kid, thinking about the differences between my family and perhaps what it was like growing up in China and now seeing the huge improvements in people's lives – I've seen vast changes while I've been there. 

"So actually it's a very human experience, one that gives me a lot of self-satisfaction. It's not just about making more money or the business aspect of it. It's about people."

Caption

Keynote speaker at Dalian 2011. /Valentine

Keynote speaker at Dalian 2011. /Valentine

Making dumplings with his Chinese friends. /Valentine

Making dumplings with his Chinese friends. /Valentine

Credits

Chief Editor Guo Chun
Editor Elizabeth Mearns
Writer Gary Parkinson
Producer Sun Lan, Elizabeth Mearns
Animation & Video James Sandifer, Sam Cordell
Camera Steve Ager