Bridge Builders: Zoe Reed
The SACU Chair recalls her extraordinary life lived between two cultures
It's a March afternoon in 1997. In Beijing's Tian'anmen Square, two groups of people walk simultaneously from different directions towards the red flag hoisted high above the famous plaza.
This is no coincidence. They have planned to meet here, to finally tie back together two strands of history – one in Britain, one in China – that have been separated for almost half a century.
But who are these people? Why has it taken so long for them to reunite? And what does it all have to do with two of the most important bridge-building Westerners in China's 20th-century history?
Humble beginnings
On March 21, 1951 a very special baby was born in London. Her humble beginnings, in a Salvation Army institution for unmarried mothers, belied the extraordinary circumstances of her existence – which was only possible thanks to a series of unlikely events involving two extraordinary Westerners.
The first was Rewi Alley, a New Zealand-born writer and political activist who was traveling around China establishing a series of industrial cooperatives and technical training schools.
The second was Joseph Needham, a Cambridge professor who was working in China for the British government supporting scientists and researching Chinese scientific history.
In 1943 Needham embarked on a long and arduous journey from Chongqing to Dunhuang, to assess where British aid might be deployed to help industrial development and improve Sino-British relations. Alley joined the trip to look for safer northern locations for schools to escape the Japanese advancing from the south, and he brought along a couple of teenage Chinese students to do the cooking and cleaning.
The group bonded during the trip, and Needham wanted to give something back to the younger men. When they completed their education in 1947, he offered to bring them to the UK for technical training.
One of them, Sun Kuang-chun, studied textile engineering in Nottingham, becoming the first ever mature Chinese student funded by the British United Aid to China. He would also, as you may by now have guessed, become Zoe Reed's father.
Rewi Alley in China
It's entirely apt that Rewi Alley's old house in Beijing is now the offices of the Chinese People's Association for Friendship with Foreign Countries – the organization which manages China's twin-city relationships.
Alley was born in New Zealand in 1897. While on medal-winning duty in World War I, he met Chinese support workers; in 1927, he moved to China for what turned out to be 60 years.
Initially intending to join the police, Alley instead became a factory inspector – and inadvertently found his vocation. He became a key figure in the establishment of Chinese industrial cooperatives, setting up technical training schools and stimulating grassroots economic development.
At first he was based near Shanghai, but under threat of Japan invasion from the coast, he was forced to seek safer areas farther inland. Another Westerner seeking to venture into China's interior was Joseph Needham, so he and Alley teamed up.
Alley – who had already adopted two young Chinese boys – suggested they bring along two bright teenage students to help out, Wang Wensheng and Sun Kuang Chuan. The latter would become Zoe Reed's father.
Rewi Alley died in Beijing in 1987, after a 90-year life of activism and education. There are memorials to him in his New Zealand hometown, at the Lanzhou city University College, and in Shandan, where there is a replica of his former home.
Unplanned pregnancy
"So how on earth did my mother and father meet?" chuckles Zoe Reed. "My mother, who had an interesting take on life and would take chances, was very ambitious, very bright."
Living just outside London and working in a bookshop, Susan Reed took a chance that would change her life when she entered a Cooperative Society competition to write an essay on international relations. She won, earning a place at Stanford Hall Cooperative College in Nottinghamshire, where 103 people from all over the world were staying and studying. She was one of only three women in the group; one of the 100 men was Sun Kuang-chun, known to his new English friends as KC.
"She had a pretty good choice of which young man to fall in love with and told me there was a chap from Iceland she quite liked," smiles Zoe Reed. "But it was my father from China with whom she fell in love. They had a strong romance together."
The affair lasted for two years, but the pressure of a cross-cultural relationship, plus Sun's desire to return to China, led them to go their separate ways in 1950. But as we now know, that wasn't the end of that story.
"After my father had gone back to China, my mother found herself pregnant," says Zoe Reed. Panic-stricken, she turned for help to a benefactor she didn't know: "My mother hadn't actually met Joseph Needham, so she wrote him a letter."
"Dear Dr Needham,
I wonder if you would help me. You do not know me, of course, but by way of introduction, I can say that I am that Susan Reed that KC Sun talked of marrying a couple of years ago. Needless to say, we both thought better of it, but I now find myself in the quite terrible situation of going to have his child in March.
"I understand from Mrs Atherton of Holywell that he's returned to China, although I have actually not seen KC Sun for four months at least. I have been working since June in the children's home near Holywell.
"I would not have bothered you now as I realise that all this has come about entirely through my own fault, were it not for the fact that I have run into considerably more trouble than I had bargained for…"
Needham immediately wrote back, inviting her to stay with him and his wife Dorothy (or 'Dophi') for the weekend to discuss their options. The obvious choice was to have the child adopted, and the Needhams went to great lengths to help place the child with an agency; when agencies displayed little enthusiasm for a mixed-ethnicity baby, they tried to place her with a family themselves.
But when little Zoe came along, her mother had a change of heart and she found herself writing to the Needhams again: "Dear Dophi and Joseph, I'm terribly sorry, but I've fallen in love with her, so I'm not going to let her be adopted. I'm going to keep her."
Who was Joseph Needham?
Born in 1900 and dying in 1995, Noel Joseph Terence Montgomery Needham had a long life – but filled it with boundless energy and inquisitiveness. The brilliant mind that made him a noted scientist was also restless enough to make him a pivotal historian, while his global thinking helped him establish UNESCO and become a noted Sinologist.
Needham came from good stock: his father was a successful Harley Street doctor, his mother a composer who became the first female to conduct at the Royal Albert Hall. He studied medicine at Cambridge but switched for his PhD to the evolving modern science of biochemistry.
He became known as the "father of chemical embryology" after extensive research tracing the discipline's history back to its Egyptian roots, but in 1937 his world changed when three Chinese scientists came to study at Cambridge. One, Shen Shih-Chang, was under his tutelage; one, Lu Gwei-djen, was under his wife Dorothy Moyle Needham, also a Cambridge biochemist.
Fascinated with Chinese culture, Needham learnt the language from Lu (who would eventually, after Dorothy's death 50 years later, become his second wife). Convinced that China's ancient technological and scientific past was a relatively untapped wellspring of knowledge, Needham took perilous wartime trips to China, collecting historical scientific books to ship home for further study.
He planned a book, Science and Civilisation in China, which quickly grew to seven volumes and is still expanding (it's currently on 27). Needham's research showed that several crucial inventions and concepts previously thought to be Western firsts had already happened in China, including gunpowder, printing, the magnetic compass, cast iron, the stirrup and the plowshare.
Needham was also involved in the establishment of UNESCO, the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization: indeed, it was he who insisted the S was as crucial as the E and the C. Invited on board by UNESCO's first director Julian Huxley (brother of Brave New World novelist Aldous), he became the first head of the agency's natural sciences section.
Suspicious of the Eurocentric view of human intellectual development, Needham became one of the West's foremost Sinologists and fervently encouraged cooperation between cultures that were, in the third quarter of the 20th century, sharply divided along political lines. In 1965, with career diplomat Derek Bryan, he established the Society for Anglo-Chinese Understanding.
Respected in his home country, Needham is regarded in China as a hero twice over – firstly for recognizing, cataloging and proselytizing about the country's scientific heritage, and then for promoting greater global cooperation and understanding.
Throughout Zoe's childhood, she and her mother would spend occasional weekends with the Needhams. "They would always remember birthdays and Christmas. We always got a book which they thought would be good to read – mostly about China," she smiles. "They were kind of there in the background, to spend time with, and as a support."
Few children had such a famous benefactor as Joseph Needham, who gave her a Chinese'Li', the same name as them. However, Susan Reed had been abandoned by her birth family and still faced a lot of prejudice and hardship bringing up Zoe alone.
"As you can imagine, in those days there was a lot of intolerance, and not a lot support for what many called 'half-caste children'. My mother was on her own and having to carve a life for both of us, and that meant taking a number of jobs."
While Susan moved from job to job, Zoe had periods of foster care and lots of 'aunties' to look after her – but her father went unmentioned, and she had no contact with her Chinese heritage.
"I remember nobody ever spoke about my father. In fact, what I was told was that he was dead. That was kind of an easy way of handling the lack of connection. And it made sense, and it meant the aunties and uncles in the various schools that I went to, my Chineseness was ignored. It was not really part of the story."
When Zoe was at Chelsea College, her mother finally told her that her father may not be dead but had been unreachable in China. He hadn't replied to a series of letters that her mother had written in Zoe's early years, so she had no way of contacting him. Zoe was told that the only person who would know if he was alive or how to contact him was Joseph Needham.
"It's interesting that all those years I was going back and forth, Joseph and Dorothy were trying to educate me about China. I wasn't paying a lot of attention to the books. It must have been silent between us all as to whether my father was dead or alive or how to contact him."
In 1973 Zoe wrote to Needham, who replied:
"My dear Zoe Kim, Dophi and I were very pleased to get your letter of 11th of November and to know not only that you now know about your father KC Sun, but that you've been inspired by it. I can assure you that he was an absolute charmer when young and I'm sure must be a fine man – a textile engineer now, if he is still living, as we all hope."
Although Needham was unable to contact her father, Zoe somehow knew their paths would one day cross. "I always thought he was alive," she says. "And I thought 'I'm going to get to see him, and he's going to be an opportunity for me to then connect with China' – whereas up until then, I'd completely suppressed it."
Reaching out
After Joseph Needham died in 1995, Zoe attended his memorial service and met HT Huang, who had been Needham's secretary and went along on the 1943 trip across China. He agreed to help her track down her father.
Huang wrote to Madam Wang, Sun's old schoolteacher in China, telling her that Sun had a daughter in the West and that she would like to meet him if it's OK. Wang contacted Sun and asked him to see her; he bicycled over to her flat to be told the news.
"He went back and discussed it with his family, and they decided to welcome me into the family," Zoe says. And on February 28, 1996, a letter arrived for Zoe and her mother.
First letter from China
"My dear, how are you? How's Zoe and her family?
Hope all are very well.
Susan, I don't know how to start to write this letter. 'Susan': this name hasn't been called for nearly half a century, but today when I recall it, it's still very familiar. Life is just like a dream. We can reunion… It must be fate. In other words, we always keep in mind. Or maybe someone blessing for us, thank God, we'll become the happiest family in the world. Now we have five children – three boys and two girls. The eldest one is Zoe."
K.C. Sun kept the jumper Susan had knitted for him, on his death it was sent to Zoe. /CGTN
K.C. Sun kept the jumper Susan had knitted for him, on his death it was sent to Zoe. /CGTN
Susan kept the woven cloth that K.C. had given her and wrapped it with Zoe's baby booties. /CGTN
Susan kept the woven cloth that K.C. had given her and wrapped it with Zoe's baby booties. /CGTN
K. C. Sun's English- Mandarin dictionaries were treasured and used frequently. /CGTN Europe
K. C. Sun's English- Mandarin dictionaries were treasured and used frequently. /CGTN Europe
K. C. Sun gave Susan Reed a self portrait which she kept her whole life. /Zoe Reed.
K. C. Sun gave Susan Reed a self portrait which she kept her whole life. /Zoe Reed.
They started a written correspondence and exchanged photographs, and then Zoe decided it was time for a trip to China. Zoe and family travelled 9 hours on a plane, while Zoe's father and family travelled 36 hours on a train and they all agreed to meet under the red flag in Tiananmen Square at 3pm on March 21, 1997 – Zoe's 46th birthday.
"At 2.45pm we started to walk towards the red flag, and then we noticed the small troop of Chinese people also at quarter to three coming towards the red flag," she remembers. "So there we were, both parties had decided to come slightly early. And it was very nice – we just walked around Tiananmen Square talking."
Arriving in China, the first thing Zoe noticed was that everyone was the right height for her. Then an extraordinary sensation came over her: "But for an accident of fate, I could have been brought up in China and I could have been a Chinese person. But now I was a British person. And so it was wonderful to see the other half, to feel the other half, of myself."
At that moment she made a resolution "to accept that I was Anglo and Chinese, and to try to understand more of the Chinese take on the world and the Chinese people." And thanks to finally meeting Sun, this was no longer a fantasy: "I could become my other half because I now had a real Chinese family to relate to."
However, Zoe found it wasn't as simple as just adding a new dimension – in a different, but also sharply defined, way. She had, after all, lived for nearly 50 years without a father, and to a large extent that had shaped who she was.
"It took me a while before I called him father - I didn't know what having a father meant, really. I'd thought 'My life is fine with just a mother.' My father wanted to start being a father, and I think he thought even at 46 he could start to boss me around as a daughter."
But they worked out their new relationship to be a harmonious one for the final 11 years of Sun's life. "I had 11 years, five or six visits to China when I had a sense of a father. He was a really interesting, bright guy, but very honorable. He chose to go back to China, he wanted to help his country. He chose to do nice things and care about people."
Extract from Joseph Needham and China 2013. /A Wind Blowing from China/ Tianjin TV
Extract from Joseph Needham and China 2013. /A Wind Blowing from China/ Tianjin TV
Building understanding
Susan Reed had for years been a member of the Society for Anglo-Chinese Understanding (SACU), founded in 1965 by her old friend Joseph Needham.
"She would go and hear his lectures in London," says Zoe. "And she remained, you know, a real Joseph fan as well as knowing him."
However, Zoe – having been isolated from her Chinese heritage – didn't follow her mother into the society for a long time. "I didn't choose to join SACU, I think, until after I got my connection with my father."
"I joined SACU as an ordinary member, and in the early 2000s I came on to the SACU council," she says. "Then when the chair wanted to stand down, I was asked to take up the chair by other committee members. And so I became the chair in 2009."
By that point, SACU was somewhat struggling. Funded solely by subscriptions from its small number of members, it faced high costs – hiring halls and paying train fares for speakers.
"There wasn't a lot of activity," recalls Zoe. "So I just got involved in working with others to try and modernize it, try and make it more active."
To coincide with the 70th anniversary of Joseph Needham's famous journey through to China, in 2013 SACU organised a trip following Needham's footsteps. This was documented by Tianjin TV's 'Joseph Needham and China'.
Zoe thought hard about how to fulfill SACU's objective – to build friendship and understanding between the peoples of China and Britain. "Particularly, we were an education charity. So to educate the British public about all things to do with China and the Chinese."
One area of personal expertise with which Reed had relatable experience was her professional life in the UK's National Health Service (NHS). "I work at a senior level for a large London mental health organisation and from this position have been able to encourage building connections with mental health in China. I'd got a Chineses family and Chinese connections through SACU so it was a natural extension to bring it into my work."
From 1997 until 2019 Zoe has made 16 trips to China for SACU, NHS work and family.
Since taking over the SACU chair, Zoe pointed out the context has changed - there has been a marked rise in Sinophobia - and this has increased interest in SACU membership.
"As the West has gotten more critical of China, I think the interest in SACU from British people who actually don't think that's the right route has gotten stronger," she explains – and sure enough, she started to see more interest.
"We've got a growing number of people that are joining SACU, and I'm very excited that there's a whole number of younger people."
This reflects the growing number of British people that have lived in China to work or study. "They want to keep that connection between China and Britain alive and to tell a better story, a true story of China in their minds rather than the one they read in the Western press."